Quick Synopsis: On the eve of a major comeback performance, global pop superstar Mother Mary (Anne Hathaway) experiences a severe identity and creative crisis. Finding that her assigned stage outfit does not feel authentic to her, she reaches out to her estranged former best friend and costume designer, Sam Anselm (Michaela Coel)
All reviews are personal opinion. People can pretend it’s not, but even the most professional reviewers will allow a personal bias to infiltrate their work. Someone who is a huge fan of unicycle hockey (yes, that is a real thing, I checked) will review a film based around the subject in a different way than someone who thinks it was made up for the purposes of the film. Two people can watch exactly the same film, recognise all the same qualities and come away with completely different opinions. And neither is necessarily wrong. That’s without even considering things like personal taste, expectations and what somebody actually wants from a movie. We can talk about cinematography, performances, direction and technical achievement until we’re blue in the face, but none of that necessarily determines whether somebody enjoys what they’re watching. Sometimes a film can be brilliant and still leave you completely cold.
With that in mind, I’ll say this. I appreciate the technical brilliance of Mother Mary. I love the performances. I love how creepy it gets at times. And I love the effort that went into making it. On paper, there’s an awful lot here that should make this a film I absolutely adore. Unfortunately, things don’t always work out that way.
That being said, I didn’t love the movie. I recognise it’s well made. I can appreciate what the filmmakers are attempting to do. I can even point to individual elements that I thought worked particularly well. But when it comes to how I actually feel about the film, there’s not an awful lot there. It’s the sort of experience where I finished watching it, acknowledged that it was technically impressive, and then got on with my day. If I didn’t have to write this review, I might have even forgotten I’d watched it.
As I said, there is a lot to admire here, though. Anne Hathaway continues to impress. I firmly believe she’s got more presence than 99% of performers working today. The way she carries herself, her poise, the confidence she brings to a role, it all screams “star”. There’s something about her that makes it very easy to believe she’s somebody the entire world would want to watch. So in a way, she’s perfectly suited to playing a world-famous musical artist. You don’t have to work particularly hard to imagine her performing in front of thousands of screaming fans.
The tracks in Mother Mary (created in part by Charli XCX) have a suitably creepy quality to them. They fit the film’s atmosphere rather well, adding to that slightly unsettling feeling that runs throughout. Although if we’re talking fake music for films, I much preferred the songs from last year’s Opus. Still, the musical side of things is perhaps less interesting to me than what Hathaway does with the character herself. I really want to see her do an actual horror movie. I feel she’d absolutely nail it, either as the villain or the victim. There’s something about her performance here that makes me think she’d be particularly good at playing somebody who is genuinely terrifying, or somebody who finds themselves in an increasingly horrible situation. In Mother Mary, she’s quite creepy at times, possessing an unsettling presence that makes many of her interactions very uncomfortable. It’s not necessarily something I’d have expected from her, but it’s something I’d certainly like to see more of.
With this, and The Christophers, Michaela Coel is slowly building up an impressive portfolio of performances alongside established names. What’s particularly impressive is that she never seems overawed by the company she’s keeping. She holds her own, and there’s something quite exciting about watching an actor who seems so comfortable sharing the screen with considerably more established performers. I could see her following a similar career path to Olivia Colman. Someone who gradually builds up an impressive body of work, earns the industry’s respect and eventually finds herself receiving the sort of recognition that turns her into a household name. She’s not quite there yet, but with the right career choices, I could genuinely see her being nominated for an Academy Award in the future. And that’s not an insult to her, or to say she’s not good enough yet. At the moment, she’s giving an 8/10, but I sense she could be phenomenal.
Once I looked at who directed this, the film made a lot more sense. David Lowery previously made The Green Knight, and my feelings towards that film and Mother Mary are remarkably similar. Both are technically impressive, both are made with an incredible amount of care and detail, and both have a very strange, unsettling energy. There’s something about Lowery’s approach to filmmaking that makes his work feel quite distinctive. He seems perfectly happy to take a familiar idea and turn it into something considerably stranger, even if that means losing some of the audience along the way.
I also think both films are better experienced at home than at a cinema. They’re strange films, the kind you need to set aside a block of time to watch, and then set aside some time afterwards to get back to normal. They’re not necessarily films you can just switch off and immediately move on from. Watching at home allows you to take the film in at your own pace, which is something you need for a film like this. It’s like a very rich meal: no matter how much you’re enjoying it, it’s difficult to tackle in one sitting.
And both have similar vibes. Much like how Dance Hall Crashers seem like a ska band despite not having a brass section, Mother Mary feels like a horror movie despite not actually being one. It’s a psychological drama with horror elements. It’s not scary, but it’s not meant to be (despite how some of the marketing may have made it seem). But it is unsettling. It is creepy. There are moments that will stick with you long after the film has finished. The problem is that I remember those moments rather than the film itself. They’re interesting little highlights in an experience that never quite manages to maintain their quality. I wanted to love it considerably more than I actually did.
In summary, it’s not a bad film by any means. I admire what it sets out to achieve, and I can appreciate the craftsmanship involved. But ultimately, I came away feeling that it was a film I could appreciate without ever particularly needing to see again. If I didn’t see/review 100 films a year, my feelings towards this would be much warmer. But in a sea of other films, Mother Mary doesn’t quite do enough to be noticed.